Hell would freeze over before the prime minister would apologise for his wrongdoings.
July, the New York Times (NYT) carried a report on the apology by the
outgoing South Korean President Lee Myung-bak, for the various
corruption scandals said to have undermined his government. Several
close colleagues and relatives of the president had been prosecuted and
jailed. Many of them had influenced the workings of the government.
In recent weeks, Malaysians have noticed a succession of people who have
come forward to implicate Prime Minister Najib Tun Razak, his wife
Rosmah Mansor, his brother Nazim Abdul Razak as well as those in
positions of responsibility, such as Attorney-General Abdul Gani Patail
and Home Minister Hishammuddin Hussein.
These people, whose reputations are tarnished, appear to have no desire
to clear their names, nor deny the allegations. Have they complete
disregard for the rakyat?
Was it pure coincidence that Rosmah has announced the publication of her
biography, which she and her “publishing adviser”, Deputy Minister in
the Prime Minister’s Department, Ahmad Maslan, claim will address the
various allegations made against her? Had she been prepared for a day of
revelations by disgruntled former associates?
The pre-launch is most unusual. JK Rowling did not have a pre-launch for
her books. Most authors launch their books with a promotional tour.
What is significant about president Lee’s humiliating apology and the
NYT claim that “he could hardly lift his face”, was that when he came to
office, Lee described his government as “morally perfect”.
During his television appearance, Lee said, “The more I think about it,
the more it crushes my heart. But whom can I blame now? It’s all because
of my negligence. I bow before the people in apology”.
Hours after Lee concluded his nationwide apology, two of his colleagues
were arrested for corruption. In all, three of Lee’s relatives, four
senior presidential aides and several former senior officials in the
Cabinet and government-run companies had been implicated. Corruption menace
Malaysian leaders don’t apologise and hell would freeze over before
Najib would bow before the rakyat and apologise for his wrongdoings or
the various scandals which have hit his government.
In September 2010, a year and a half after becoming prime minister,
Najib told Malaysians that “combating corruption is not only a moral
imperative but a prerequisite for national survival”.
In a speech that was delivered by his deputy, Muhyiddin Yassin, at the
Asian Development Bank/Organisation for Economic Cooperation and
Development (ADB/OECD) Anti-Corruption Initiative for Asia and the
Pacific’s 10th Regional Seminar: Criminalisation of Bribery, Najib said
that three organisations would fight the corruption menace – the police
for investigating the criminal acts, the Attorney-General’s Chambers for
dealing with prosecutions and the Prime Minister’s Department for
“crafting the preventive eco-system”.
Najib stressed that “prevention and education should be given equal
attention alongside enforcement in the fight against corruption”.
He praised the Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission (MACC) for receiving
an increased amount of information from the public which led to investigations, arrests and prosecutions. This, Najib concluded, was a reflection of the public’s confidence in the government.
Despite the recent revelations by carpet trader Deepak Jaikishan and
former inspector-general of police Musa Hassan, the rakyat has yet to
see an investigation being initiated by the police or the MACC. The
Attorney-General’s Chambers has also remained silent.
In 2010, Najib claimed that “…studies reveal that corruptors tend to
hide themselves or their ill-gotten gains in foreign jurisdictions. The
denial of a safe haven for corruptors and their proceeds of crime is
vital in any strategy to combat corruption”.
Dirty money Recently,
the Washington-based Global Financial Integrity (GFI) reported that
around RM200 billion of illicit outflows had been recorded by Malaysia
in 2010, the highest amount for the period 2001 to 2010. The revised
figures for 2009 are estimated at RM93 billion.
According to the GFI, 20% of the dirty money are the “proceeds of
corruption, bribery theft and kickbacks” and that Malaysia was ranked
third in the world, behind China and Mexico.
If both Najib and Bank Negara are concerned, what steps are they taking
to address the issue? Will the steps be enough to allay our fears?
Last year, Najib, who is also the finance minister, said that Bank
Negara would investigate the illicit outflows, but to date, the reasons
of the illicit capital flight have not been made public.
Our government wants to emulate the South Korean work ethic and
development, but there is so much more we could learn from them, and
that is to be magnanimous and to be humble, like President Lee.
Two weeks after Lee’s elder
brother, Lee Sang-deuk, had been arrested for receiving bribes from two
bankers, the president apologised to the South Korean nation.
Two weeks after Deepak, the carpet-man, implicated Najib’s brother Nazim
in perverting the course of justice, Najib carries on as normal without
a hint of a denial or an apology.
MACC chief Abu Kassim Mohamed, who addressed the ADB/OECD Seminar in
2010, said that ethical leadership and integrity would help combat
In general, this would be true, but ethical leadership and integrity are
not to be found in Malaysia, and he should have added that corrupt
Malaysian leaders are morally bankrupt. Mariam Mokhtar is a FMT columnist.