Dr Khairul says he doubts the accuracy of the Thai pathologist's views.
Testifying before the Royal Commission of Inquiry investigating the death of Teoh Beng Hock, Dr Khairul Azman Ibrahim said he doubted the accuracy of the Thai pathologist’s views because she inspected the body long after Teoh was dead.
During the coroner’s inquest that began in 2009 and ended early this year, Pornthip testified that Teoh had suffered from pre-fall injuries evident in the bruises on his neck, which she said could have been caused by a blunt object or strangulation.
She had arrived at her conclusion after observing a second post-mortem on Teoh.
“I disagree with Pornthip’s view because she was only observing the second post-mortem and the incident happened long before the second post-mortem,” he said.
He said he and colleague Dr Prashant Naresh Samberkar did not find “such external bruises” in the first post-mortem.
What Pornthip saw, he suggested, could have been the staining caused by the breakdown of blood following the first post-mortem.
“When we opened up the neck and flipped open the skin, it would have been stretched, causing trauma to the area.”
Khairul also said invasive methods in the first post-mortem could have caused an appearance of bruises.
He told the inquiry panel he was of the opinion that when Teoh fell, the impact would have caused an “expansion and compression” of the body.
He said that was probably why a button on Teoh’s shirt popped out, his watch dislodged, his belt broke, and his trousers torn in several places.
Red dot in the eyes
Bar Council representative Christopher Leong heavily challenged Khairul’s theory, bombarding him with questions about “expansion and compression”.
However, commission chairman James Foong told Leong to change his hostile attitude.
“If this is a trial, then we need to prove beyond reasonable doubt,” Foong said. “But this is an inquiry. The best thing is to call the dead man and ask him to testify, but we can’t do that.”
In the earlier part of the proceedings, much attention was centred on the presence of petechiae (red dots in the eyes), which can indicate whether a person has been strangled.
Asked if petechiae could still be present between the first and second post-mortems, Khairul said he was unsure.
“Petechiae is caused by the increased pressure on the blood vessels and it can be seen in the form of small red dots,” he said. “It’s an important criterion for determining asphyxia, but it may not be present in all cases.”
He admitted that he mentioned petechiae in his draft report although the final post-mortem report prepared by him and Dr Prashant did not refer to it.
“To diagnose strangulation, I must have clear evidence to say it,” he said. “But in this case it is not very clear, as there is only a small abrasion on the skin which I think is due to the pen (in Teoh’s pocket).
Khairul also said he concluded, after several visits to the scene, that there was no strong evidence of homicide.
He said that if Teoh was already dead or unconscious and was thrown out, he would not have landed on his legs and the spot where he landed would have been much nearer to the wall of the building.
“If he was not conscious, his limbs could even tear right out from his body, and there would have been more lacerations as he wouldn’t have resisted the impact,” he said.
Computer simulation
Foong announced that the inquiry would include a reconstruction of Teoh’s fall by animated computer simulation.
“We have tasked our private investigator to do a scientific reconstruction on how a person would fall from such a window,” he said. “Universiti Teknologi Malaysia has indicated that they are prepared to participated in this project.”
Last Jan 5, coroner Azmil Muntapha Abas returned an open verdict, ruling out both suicide and homicide in Teoh’s death.
The current inquiry is scheduled to end on April 25, when the final report will be submitted to the Yang di-Pertuan Agong.
Teoh, the political aide to Selangor executive councillor Ean Yong Hian Wah of DAP, was found dead on July 16, 2009, on the fifth floor of Plaza Masalam, the building housing the Selangor office of the Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission (MACC).
MACC officers interrogated him the night before as a witness in the alleged misuse of Selangor government allocations.
No comments:
Post a Comment